Private & Confidential Investigation
07521 351164 Office: 01244 961766
Investigation Advice

How to Investigate Fraudulent Sickness Absence at Work

Sickness absence concerns need a fair, careful response. We explain relevant evidence, appropriate checks and why an activity alone may not prove dishonesty.

An HR professional examines absence dates and relevant work records with an investigator in a workplace meeting room
By Trojan Investigations Updated 12 November 2026

Suspected fraudulent sickness absence should be investigated as a factual employment issue, not assumed from behaviour that appears inconsistent with being off work. A fit note concerns fitness for work; it does not normally mean a person must remain at home or be incapable of every physical, social or recreational activity. Employers should define the suspected dishonesty, preserve records, follow a fair Acas-style investigation and use covert monitoring only where it is genuinely necessary, proportionate and legally justified.

At Trojan Investigations , we help organisations investigate specific discrepancies in sickness absence without turning the exercise into general monitoring of an employee's private life. The objective might be to test whether an employee is working elsewhere during claimed incapacity, undertaking activity directly inconsistent with a stated restriction, falsifying records or abusing a contractual sick-pay scheme.

How Should Suspected Fraudulent Sickness Absence Be Investigated?

  1. Define the alleged inconsistency. Avoid a vague instruction to “prove they are faking”.
  2. Review the employment record. Check absence notifications, fit notes, policies, shifts, prior explanations and any relevant occupational-health advice.
  3. Preserve time-sensitive evidence. Relevant CCTV, access logs, work records or public posts may disappear.
  4. Consider an ordinary management investigation first. Acas says an investigation should gather evidence from all sides and establish whether there is a case to answer.
  5. Use monitoring only when justified. ICO guidance treats covert worker monitoring as exceptional and requires a targeted, time-limited approach.
  6. Separate evidence from the disciplinary decision. Investigators establish facts; the employer decides what employment action follows under its policy and legal advice.
7 days is the point after which an employer can normally require a fit note for sickness absence under current GOV.UK guidance. 24 Jun 2026 is the latest Acas update date for its step-by-step workplace investigation guidance used in this article. Exceptional is the ICO's approach to covert worker monitoring: it is unlikely to be justified in most ordinary circumstances.

Being Seen Outside the Home Is Not Proof of Fraud

An employee signed off with stress may be encouraged to exercise or see friends. Someone with a back condition may be capable of short periods of movement but not a full shift involving lifting. A person may be medically unfit for one job while still able to perform a different activity.

The evidential question should therefore be specific: what did the employee represent about their condition or restrictions, what does the role require and what observed behaviour is said to contradict that? Without that comparison, surveillance can produce dramatic-looking footage that proves very little.

Evidence in a suspected sickness-absence investigation
Evidence What it may establish What it does not automatically prove
Fit note Healthcare assessment of fitness for work and possible adjustments That the employee must remain at home or cannot undertake any activity
Absence notifications What the employee told the employer and when Medical diagnosis beyond what was actually disclosed
Work or access records Attendance, system use, vehicle or premises activity Dishonesty without context
Public social-media material Publicly visible dates, claims or activities That the post was created on the day it was uploaded or shows the full circumstances
Lawful surveillance Observed conduct at specific times and places Medical fitness for a job; that assessment may require medical evidence
Witness account What another person says they saw or were told Truth unless credibility and context are assessed
Manager reviews a staff-policy binder beside a closed absence file.

Start with the Employment Policy and the Allegation

The employer should identify which rule may have been breached: dishonesty, false information, unauthorised secondary work, breach of an exclusivity or conflict provision, abuse of contractual sick pay, failure to follow notification procedures or some other obligation. The investigation then tests that proposition.

Our business investigation services can support the fact-finding stage, but the employer remains responsible for its employment process. Acas guidance stresses that the investigator should not set out to prove guilt and should gather evidence from all sides.

Fit Notes Need to Be Interpreted Properly

GOV.UK states that employees generally self-certify for the first seven calendar days and may be asked for a fit note after that. A fit note can say “not fit for work” or “may be fit for work” with suggested adjustments.

It is not a certificate that every movement or activity is prohibited. If the employer needs a medical view about whether observed conduct is inconsistent with a health condition, occupational-health or other appropriate medical advice may be more reliable than an investigator making a medical inference.

Health Information Requires Extra Care

Medical and health information is sensitive personal information. Access should be limited to people who need it, and collection should be relevant to the employment purpose. A private investigator should not be instructed to obtain confidential medical records or impersonate the employee to access health information.

If the employer seeks a medical report, current GOV.UK fit-note guidance says the employee's permission is required for the employer to ask a healthcare professional for a report about their health.

Disability and Reasonable Adjustments Can Change the Analysis

Some sickness absence may be disability-related. Acas explains that employers may need to make reasonable adjustments to absence policies, including adjustments to trigger points, where that is reasonable. The Equality Act 2010 protects disabled workers and applies to discipline and dismissal as well as working arrangements.

An investigation should therefore keep the dishonesty question separate from capability and disability issues. Genuine absence can still create operational problems, but that does not make it fraudulent.

Investigate Conduct, Not the Diagnosis

A private investigator can document factual activity. They should not diagnose a condition, declare that a person is medically fit for work or treat a disability-related absence as misconduct merely because the employee is visible outside the home. Medical fitness and reasonable adjustments require the appropriate employment and health process.

HR reviewer considers a limited monitoring proposal with equipment still packed away.

When Can Covert Monitoring Be Considered?

The ICO says covert worker monitoring is unlikely to be justified in most usual circumstances, but may be justifiable exceptionally where it is necessary to prevent or detect suspected criminal activity or an equivalent such as gross misconduct.

The ICO guidance also says covert monitoring should be authorised by senior management, supported by a DPIA, targeted to the suspected conduct, limited to the shortest possible period and stopped once the investigation is complete. It should not intrude into places where workers reasonably expect privacy.

Surveillance Should Be Narrowly Targeted

If lawful observation is justified, our surveillance services can focus on a defined time window and factual question. For example, the issue may be whether an employee repeatedly works a physically demanding second job during hours when they have represented that they cannot perform materially similar work for their employer.

That is different from open-ended monitoring designed to catalogue the employee's private life. The instruction should state what evidence would be relevant and what should be ignored.

Do Not Turn One Suspicious Photograph into a Disciplinary Conclusion

A holiday photograph may be old, a public post may be scheduled, a person can have good and bad days, and many health conditions do not prevent all activity. Evidence needs context before it is relied upon.

Preserve Internal Evidence Before It Is Deleted

Employer Evidence Checklist

  • Sickness notifications and dates.
  • Fit notes and return-to-work records.
  • Relevant absence and sick-pay policies.
  • The employee's normal role and physical or attendance requirements.
  • Shift schedules and approved leave.
  • Access-control records where lawfully held.
  • Relevant company-vehicle records.
  • Business-system or work-output records that are genuinely relevant.
  • Public material supplied to the employer, with URL and capture date.
  • Witness accounts recorded fairly.
  • Existing occupational-health advice where the employer is entitled to use it.
  • Any previous explanation provided by the employee.

How the Investigation Should Progress

1. Write the Allegation Neutrally

Describe the suspected inconsistency without assuming dishonesty.

2. Plan the Evidence

Acas recommends an investigation plan identifying witnesses, evidence sources, time limits, policies, timescales and confidentiality.

3. Gather Both Supporting and Contrary Material

The investigator should look for evidence that supports and does not support the allegation.

4. Put Relevant Matters to the Employee Through the Employer's Process

Surveillance evidence should not replace a fair opportunity to explain apparently inconsistent conduct.

5. Report Facts, Then Let the Employer Decide

If the matter may involve litigation or external proceedings, our legal and litigation support can help structure the factual evidence for solicitor review without taking over the employer's disciplinary decision.

What Should the Investigation Report Say?

Acas guidance recommends a written report once enough information has been gathered, including which facts were established, which were not established and any mitigating circumstances requiring consideration. If relevant information is omitted without good reason, the fairness of the process may be undermined.

A private-investigator report should therefore avoid declaring an employee “guilty of sickness fraud”. It should document what was observed, how, when and with what limitations, leaving the employer to make the employment decision under its policy and advice.

The Aim Is a Fair Answer, Not a Predetermined Dismissal

A well-run investigation may confirm misconduct, show that the concern was misunderstood or identify a legitimate health or workplace issue that needs support rather than discipline. Each is a useful outcome if the evidence is reliable.

When to Instruct an External Investigator

External help can be useful when the allegation is sensitive, internal relationships create conflicts, specialist surveillance is being considered or the business needs independent factual reporting. It should not be used to bypass HR responsibilities or employment law.

Employers can book a confidential consultation to define the allegation, evidence already held, legal constraints and whether investigative work is actually necessary before monitoring begins.

Separate Suspected Dishonesty from Capability and Attendance Management

An employer may have legitimate concerns about an employee's attendance even where there is no dishonesty. Frequent genuine absence, inability to fulfil a role and a false sickness claim are different issues and may require different procedures. Combining them into one allegation can make the investigation unfair and harder to defend.

The investigator should therefore be told whether the concern is that the employee lied about being ill, misrepresented a restriction, worked elsewhere in breach of contract, obtained sick pay dishonestly or simply has an absence level the employer is struggling to manage. The evidence needed for each is different.

Secondary Employment Is Not Automatically Sickness Fraud

A person can be unfit for one job but capable of another. A warehouse operative with a physical restriction may still be able to carry out desk-based freelance work; an employee signed off because of a particular workplace stressor may be capable of activity elsewhere. Contractual rules about second jobs, conflicts and notification can still matter, but those are separate questions from medical fitness.

Evidence of other work should therefore be compared with the employee's representations, job demands and contract rather than presented as automatic proof that the sickness absence was false.

Public Social-Media Evidence Needs Date and Context Checks

A photograph uploaded during sickness absence may have been taken months earlier. A video can be reposted, edited or lack context. Public material may provide a lead, but the investigator should preserve the URL, visible account, capture date and surrounding text before making any inference.

Employers should also avoid instructing colleagues to connect with the employee deceptively or gain access to private posts through false accounts. The privacy setting itself should be respected.

The Employee Should Have a Fair Opportunity to Explain

Acas guidance treats workplace investigation as fact finding, not a substitute for the later disciplinary process. Apparently strong surveillance evidence can have an innocent explanation: a brief activity recommended as rehabilitation, an old social post, a family member using a vehicle or an activity that does not conflict with the fit note.

The employer should consider the employee's explanation alongside the investigator's material. A private investigator should not conduct the disciplinary hearing or recommend a sanction unless separately instructed in a role that is compatible with the organisation's procedure.

Proportionality Should Be Reassessed as the Case Develops

If early evidence shows the allegation is mistaken, monitoring should stop. If internal records resolve the question, there may be no need for surveillance. If the issue becomes medical rather than disciplinary, occupational-health input may be more appropriate.

Likewise, if evidence points to a serious dishonest scheme involving forged documents or organised payroll abuse, the employer may need legal advice, insurer notification or police involvement rather than simply extending private surveillance.

A Fit Note Is Evidence of Fitness for Work, Not a Requirement to Stay Indoors

Employers should be careful not to treat ordinary activity as automatic contradiction of sickness absence. A person may be unfit for their particular job while still being able to shop, exercise, travel locally or carry out an activity recommended as part of recovery. The significance depends on the stated limitation, the employee's role, any medical information lawfully available and what the observed activity actually demonstrates.

That is why surveillance footage should be described factually rather than labelled “fraudulent” by the investigator. The employer can then test it against attendance records, the employee's explanation, occupational-health or medical evidence where appropriate, and the Acas process before reaching any disciplinary conclusion.

Frequently Asked Questions About Suspected Fraudulent Sickness Absence

Answers about fit notes, surveillance, covert monitoring, disability, evidence and fair workplace investigations when sickness absence is disputed.


Does Being Seen Outside the House Prove an Employee Is Faking Sickness?

No. Fitness for work is not the same as being incapable of all activity. The relevance of an observation depends on the condition, job, restrictions represented and the specific conduct observed.

Can an Employer Investigate Suspected Sickness Absence Fraud?

Yes, but it should follow a fair and reasonable process, define the allegation, gather evidence from both sides and comply with employment and data-protection obligations.

Can a Private Investigator Follow an Employee Who Is Off Sick?

Potentially, where surveillance is lawful, necessary and proportionate to a defined investigation. Covert monitoring of workers requires particularly careful justification under ICO guidance.

Do We Need a Dpia Before Covert Employee Monitoring?

ICO guidance says employers considering covert worker monitoring should carry out a Data Protection Impact Assessment and be able to justify the necessity and proportionality of the monitoring.

Can an Employee Be Disciplined While They Have a Fit Note?

A fit note does not prevent an employer investigating alleged misconduct, but the process must be fair and any health, disability or participation issues should be handled appropriately.

Can a Fit Note Be Challenged by Surveillance Footage?

Surveillance can document conduct, but investigators are not medical assessors. If the significance of the conduct depends on medical fitness, appropriate medical or occupational-health advice may be needed.

Can We Monitor an Employee’s Private Social Media Account?

Employers and investigators should not bypass privacy controls or use unauthorised access. Publicly available material may be considered where relevant and processed lawfully.

Can We Secretly Record the Employee at Home?

Intrusive monitoring in private spaces is highly problematic and may be unlawful. Worker monitoring should not be conducted in locations where there is a strong reasonable expectation of privacy.

What If the Employee Has a Disability?

The employer must consider Equality Act duties, including reasonable adjustments where applicable. Disability-related absence should not automatically be treated as misconduct.

Can an Employee Work Another Job While Signed Off Sick?

It depends on the circumstances, contracts, medical restrictions and nature of each role. The fact of secondary work may be relevant, but it does not automatically prove fraud.

Should the Investigator Interview the Employee?

Often the employer or appointed workplace investigator handles the investigation meeting. Any interview should be part of a fair process and should not assume guilt.

Can CCTV and Vehicle Records Be Used?

Potentially, where the employer lawfully holds the records and their use is relevant, necessary and consistent with data-protection requirements and workplace policies.

How Long Should Surveillance Continue?

Only as long as is necessary to answer the defined question. ICO guidance says covert monitoring should be targeted and limited to the shortest possible period.

What Should the Final Report Conclude?

It should state established and unestablished facts, evidence, limitations and relevant mitigating circumstances. The employer makes the disciplinary decision.

When Should We Call the Police?

If the evidence indicates a criminal offence, the employer may consider police involvement. Acas notes that employers can continue their own investigation where reasonable but should take care not to prejudice criminal proceedings.

Not Sure Where to Start?

Tell us what happened and what you need to establish. We’ll discuss the options before you decide.

BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION
Practical Advice

Helpful Reading Before You Decide

A Private First Conversation

You Do Not Have to Work It Out Alone

Tell us what has happened. We will listen, explain the options and help you decide whether an investigation is the right next step.

Call Our Team BOOK A FREE CONSULTATION

Search Trojan Investigations

Enter at least two characters.

Choose whether to load these optional services. You can change your mind using Cookie Settings in the footer.

Cookie Policy · Privacy Policy